Home All NGO Projects REF – THE ROMA EDUCATION FUND: IS IT CLOSING, OPENING OR JUST...

REF – THE ROMA EDUCATION FUND: IS IT CLOSING, OPENING OR JUST TURNING THE KEY? WHO IS MAKING A FOOL OF WHOM?

30
0

Twenty years, millions of euros, hundreds of presentations and one big question: WHERE ARE THE EDUCATED ROMA?

Welcome to the world of Roma education, where sometimes it seems easier to launch a new project than to explain what happened to the previous one!

The leading character in this story is the Roma Education Fund (REF), an organisation that for many years was presented as one of the key mechanisms for improving Roma education in Europe.

Founded in Switzerland, later headquartered in Budapest, operating in several European countries and supported by international donors, REF spent years promoting the promise of a better educational future for Roma communities.

And this is where our little comedy begins.

Public estimates associated with its long-term activities refer to approximately €100 million over the years. Sixteen countries, millions of Roma people and enormous numbers of potential beneficiaries are part of this story.

Just imagine! With that kind of money, one might reasonably expect to see an entire army of Roma professors, doctors, engineers, lawyers, scientists and university lecturers today.

Perhaps someone might even be ready to succeed the Fund’s director!

But wait a moment. Before celebrating this great educational success, let us examine what actually happened.

After so many years, where is the final balance sheet? How many Roma pupils completed secondary education? How many graduated from universities? How many obtained master’s and doctoral degrees? How many are now employed and contributing to the development of their communities?

Or perhaps the greatest educational achievement is that we now have more and more experts in writing projects, while we are still waiting to see a sufficiently large number of educated Roma?

AND NOW, LET US LOOK AT OUR LITTLE PERFORMANCE IN NORTH MACEDONIA!

The announcement looked spectacular. An agenda was prepared, ministers, directors, senior representatives, panellists and experts were expected. One might have thought that a European summit was coming, perhaps even the founding of a new era in Roma education!

A serious event, serious discussions and serious answers were expected.

But apparently, the event itself had a problem with its own agenda.

Here is how the comedy unfolded: the organisers prepared the agenda, printed it and put it on the wall of the conference room. The participants then had to get up, walk over to the wall and read what was actually supposed to happen!

Apparently, the agenda was the most reliable participant at the conference. It did not need a plane ticket, did not request a hotel, did not require an honorarium and remained present from beginning to end!

All it needed was a microphone. Perhaps it could even have delivered a better presentation.

The announced guests and panellists did not appear in the expected line-up, and reality turned out to be rather different from the official programme. REF Director Ciprian also did not personally attend the event in North Macedonia, despite the institutional importance attached to it.

Of course, perhaps he had a more important agenda. But when an organisation has spent years working on Roma education, is it not reasonable to expect its director to meet the people whose educational future the institution is supposed to serve?

Or is holding the position of director enough to be present even when one is physically absent?

AND WHAT ABOUT THE SCHOLARSHIPS? HERE COMES THE REAL MATHEMATICS!

During the presentation, we heard about scholarships worth €400, €800 and even more. That sounds good. Every form of support for Roma pupils and students is welcome.

But somehow, nobody presented the complete mathematical calculation.

What is the real cost of one scholarship when all programme expenses are included? How much goes towards administration, project managers, coordinators, mentors, tutors, mediators, management structures and other institutional expenses?

We are not saying these positions are unnecessary. Of course people should be paid for their work. But when money is intended for Roma education, the public has the right to know how much reaches the student and how much is spent maintaining the system around that student.

Perhaps somebody should introduce a new scholarship category: a scholarship for project managers, so they can continue their studies in how to keep projects going!

AND NOW, THE BIGGEST MYSTERY: IS REF CLOSING OR OPENING?

This is beginning to resemble a familiar children’s game: open the door, close the door, turn the key and open it again!

On one hand, there is talk of closing the existing institutional structure. On the other, there are announcements that project support will continue through funding associated with George Soros.

So what exactly is closing? What is continuing? Who will manage it? Who will select the projects? Who will oversee the money? And, most importantly, who will be accountable for the results of the previous two decades?

Is it only the address, the logo, the director or the entire operating model that is changing?

If the institution is being transformed, the Roma public deserves a clear explanation, not another presentation entitled “A New Vision for the Future”.

Roma already have enough visions. What they need are concrete results.

AND WHERE IS EUROPEAN ACCOUNTABILITY?

The European Union and international donors should ask one simple question: how long will programmes continue to receive funding while presenting themselves as successful without providing the public with a complete and comparable picture of their long-term results?

It is not enough for an organisation to be well organised, with offices, directors, experts, reports and international conferences.

An organisation may have perfect administration while its beneficiaries are still waiting for real change.

Roma education is not the private property of any foundation, any director or any group of project managers.

It is the right of an entire generation.

AND FINALLY, ONE LITTLE RECOMMENDATION FOR REF’S NEXT EVENT.

Instead of organising yet another conference with ministers, directors, panellists and an agenda stuck to the wall, perhaps it is time to organise a different kind of event.

Bring all the documentation covering twenty years of activities. Open the financial reports. Present the results. Invite former scholarship recipients.

Show us where those young people are today, what they have achieved, where they work and what difference they have made in Roma communities.

And Director Ciprian, instead of another presentation, perhaps you could bring a large calculator. Maybe we can finally calculate the difference between the millions invested and the results achieved.

And if the question arises once again whether REF is closing or opening, perhaps the best solution would be to put a large notice on the door:

“PROGRAMME IN PROGRESS. RESULTS UNDER PREPARATION. FOR ANSWERS, PLEASE ATTEND OUR NEXT CONFERENCE.”

Of course, this is just a joke. But the questions are serious.

SO, WHO IS MAKING A FOOL OF WHOM?

Those who believed that millions of euros would create an educational revolution, or those who still expect the Roma public to be satisfied with another panel, another presentation and another new strategy?

After twenty years, Roma youth should not be extras in somebody else’s projects. They should be the main achievement of those projects.

Because education is not measured by the number of conferences, the thickness of reports or the number of employees in a foundation.

IT IS MEASURED BY HOW MANY EDUCATED ROMA PEOPLE WE HAVE LEFT BEHIND!

And, gentlemen, that cannot be read from an agenda stuck to a wall. It must be demonstrated through results.

Any resemblance to reality is not accidental. The questions are public, and the Roma community is waiting for answers.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here